Carbon fiber with reinforced polyetheretherketone (CFR-PEEK) plating and nailing for intercalary resection with tibial allograft reconstruction in two oncologic patients
Article History
-
Received: ,
Accepted: ,
Abstract
Abstract
Carbon fiber with reinforced polyetheretherketone (CFR-PEEK) implants have been utilized and researched in orthopedic trauma; however, CFR-PEEK implants may also have potential in orthopedic oncology. Therefore, the purpose of this case series was to report post-operative outcomes and radiographic healing of two patients who received CFR-PEEK plating and nailing for intercalary tumor resection with tibial allograft.
Two patients who underwent CFR-PEEK plating and nailing for intercalary resection with tibial allograft reconstruction were identified. Post-operative encounters were evaluated for any complications, reoperations, and progress of radiographic healing.
The first patient was diagnosis with adamantinoma and ultimately had a complication-free recovery throughout 2.5-year follow-up. The second patient presented with a recurrent proximal tibia osteosarcoma after tibial curettage 14 years prior, and has had a complication-free recovery throughout 1-year follow-up. The radiographic time to union was determined to be six months for both patients and was confirmed with clinical examination.
Both patients who received CFR-PEEK plating and nailing for intercalary resection with tibial allograft had a successful surgical recovery with no post-operative complications. CFR-PEEK implants may be safe and effective for intercalary resection with tibial allograft, however future larger comparative studies are needed.
IV.
Keywords
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1 Introduction
Prior to the surgical and imaging advances observed in the 1970s, patients with lower extremity tumors were typically treated with amputation of the affected lower limb. Limb salvage surgery now provides patients with better functional outcomes and increased survival rates than amputation.1 Specifically, intercalary resection with tibial allograft has become a favored surgical technique of orthopedic oncologists, which provides a biological spacer allowing immediate knee joint function.2,3 Various tibial allograft sizes may be prepared which are progressively incorporated by the patient at the host–donor junctions.2 Intercalary tibial allografts also provide major advantages by allowing for biological reconstruction of the affected tibial long bone without donor site morbidity, preserving the anatomic locations for tendon insertion, and providing a scaffold for union.3–7
Despite these benefits, reconstruction after intercalary resection with tibial allograft is challenging surgically due to the poor vascularity of the tibia and the subcutaneous location of the surgical site.2 Several retrospective studies have evaluated the post-operative outcomes of patients after intercalary resection, finding acceptable survivorship rates and excellent functional outcomes.2,4,8–12 Survivorship rates of specifically tibial allografts have been estimated to be 84 % at 5 years and 79 % at 10 years post-operatively.2 However, complications of intercalary allograft reconstruction are common, with the most common major complications being non-union, graft fracture, and infection.4 A nationwide evaluation of 87 oncology patients who underwent long bone reconstruction with intercalary allograft found that 66 (76 %) patients experienced a complication and 40 (46 %) patients had two or more complications.4 The prevalence of complications after reconstruction with intercalary allograft highlights the need for surgical innovation regarding this procedure.
One potential source of innovation that may improve post-operative outcomes for reconstruction intercalary tibial allograft is CarboFix implants (Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina, USA), which are made of continuous carbon fibers with reinforced polyetheretherketone (CFR-PEEK) polymer. CFR-PEEK implants have been utilized and researched in orthopedic trauma treatment of wrist, humerus, femur, and ankle fractures.13–17 CFR-PEEK implants may also have great potential in orthopedic oncology, however minimal research has been conducted on these implants in oncologic patients.18
Therefore, the purpose of this case series is to report the surgical technique, post-operative outcomes, and radiographic healing of two patients who received CarboFix CFR-PEEK plating and nailing for intercalary tumor resection with tibial allograft reconstruction.
2 Methods
2.1 Patient screening
IRB exemption (Capital Health IRB #00002877) was received to perform a retrospective medical records review to identify patients who underwent plating and nailing with CarboFix CFR-PEEK implants (Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina, USA). Two patients who underwent CarboFix implant plating and nailing for intercalary resection (CPT code 27645) with tibial allograft reconstruction were identified, both operated on by the same fellowship-trained orthopaedic oncology surgeon (J.A.A.). Assistance with the soleus or gastrocnemius flap was provided by a fellowship-trained plastic surgeon. A minimum of 1-year clinical and imaging follow-up were available for both patients.
2.2 Surgical technique
The patient was positioned supine and tourniquet was raised to 250 mmHg. An anterior incision was made with a 15 blade and then dissection of the skin, tibialis anterior, and periosteum was completed. A sleeve of periosteum 1 cm both proximally and distally was carefully removed so it could be placed over the junction later. Location of the tibialis anterior artery proximally and distally allowed for careful protection.
Malleable retractors were used to protect soft tissue while a saw was used to make proximal and distal bone cuts for removal of the tumor specimen. A curette was then used to remove proximal and distal marrow margins for lab evaluation, which both returned as negative.
Allograft reconstruction was then begun. The removed specimen was used as a template for marking proximal and distal cuts from the allograft, which was ordered preoperatively to match the tibia based on pre-operative imaging. After the cuts were made, a burr was used to smoothen the cuts, and a guidewire was placed in the bone and reamed up to a size 12. This allograft was then inserted into the defect for intramedullary nailing.
After a proximal knee incision was made and both skin and subcutaneous tissue were dissected, the medial aspect paratenon of the tendon was identified and dissected towards. A guidewire was driven in the medial-proximal start point of the paratenon and adjusted with both anteroposterior and lateral images. Once in an optimal position, the guidewire was reamed over with a 13 mm canal opening drill, and then a long guidewire was used to ream to a size 12.5. A CarboFix 11 × 300 mm nail was then inserted through the tibia and the allograft, continuously rotating appropriately and maintaining a tight junction. C-arm images were then taken to confirm appropriate position, and a distal interlock was placed using a standard perfect circle technique. A back slapper was then used on the tibia to gain compression at both allograft junctions. The proximal interlock screw was placed in a standard fashion, and attention was then turned to plating.
A CarboFix 13 hole diaphyseal plate was placed on the lateral aspect of the tibia and allograft beneath the tibialis anterior. The hole plate was placed in a proximal position and clamped with a bridge clamp, and was then attached to the bone with periprosthetic screws. Two screws were used on both ends of the host bone, and 1 screw at each end of the allograft. Finally, the surgical sites were irrigated thoroughly and the referred plastic surgeon performed a soleus or gastrocnemius flap as planned.
2.3 Data collection
The following demographic and intra-operative variables were collected: age, sex, relevant social and medical history, body mass index (BMI), laterality, previous surgery, presenting symptoms, imaging findings, pathologic diagnosis, as well as intra-operative estimated blood loss and complications. All post-operative encounters were also evaluated for any post-operative complications, progression of union, reoperations, or recurrence of disease. Time to radiographic union was also assessed, with haziness at the fibula-host bone junction or between the allograft and host bone, as well as a deterioration of the osteotomy line, as signs for assessing union. Time to union was confirmed clinically by physical examination. No statistical analyses were performed due to sample size.
3 Results
Medical records review identified 2 patients with who underwent CarboFix implant plating for intercalary resection with tibial allograft.
3.1 Patient 1
Patient 1 was a female 21 years of age with a BMI of 19.9 kg/m2 who presented with a painless mass that has steadily grown over 3 months on the mid shaft region of the right tibial area, extending anteriorly. The patient had no limitations to her activities of daily living. There were no positive physical examination findings besides identification and palpation of the subcutaneous mass, which was about 3 cm in length and 3 cm in width. Radiographic and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) suggested adamantinoma as the primary diagnosis, with fibrous dysplasia also possible, due to a soap-bubble abnormality of the tibial anterior cortex and infiltration of the mass through the bone and into the soft tissue anteriorly. Pathology later confirmed the primary diagnosis of adamantinoma, and surgical resection with tibial allograft reconstruction was planned.
Patient 1 experienced 300 cc of blood loss during her intercalary resection with tibial allograft with no intra-operative complications. Unfortunately, it was found that some positive margins were present on the soft tissue margins, but the procedure did remove the maximum amount of tumor specimen possible without requiring a free flap and skin graft. More importantly the bone margins were negative, which are more important for recurrence, but the patient will be monitored closely to ensure early identification of any recurrence.
The patient had no early post-operative complications, with minimal pain and had achieved 90° of knee flexion and full knee extension by six weeks post-op. By 6 months post-operatively, the patient was back to full activity and felt her legs had similar function bilaterally. Significant healing was observed on 6-month radiographs, with definitive full healing observed at 9 months. At latest follow-up of 2.5 years post-operatively, the patient was still pain-free with full function and no signs of recurrence.
3.2 Patient 2
Patient 2 was a male 23 years of age with a BMI of 28.4 kg/m2 who is a former smoker and presented with a recurrent mass at the proximal tibia. The patient underwent tibial curettage with allograft at 9 years old, and was symptomless for 14 years until three months prior to his initial appointment. The patient presented with minimal pain (1 out of 10), chronic numbness over the anterolateral aspect of his lower leg, and no significant limitations to daily living. There were no positive physical examination findings except palpation of a mass extending 5.5 cm. MRI showed multiple foci of current tumor in the proximal tibial diaphysis, with some erosion about the anterolateral tibial cortex, and a well circumscribed medial margin of the tumor mass with thick cortical boundaries. The initial diagnosis was recurrence of a low-grade osteosarcoma, which was later confirmed by pathology, resulting in the planning of a surgical resection with tibial allograft reconstruction.
Patient 1 experienced no intra-operative complications. Sampled margins were tested and found to be negative, and the procedure was completed with a gastrocnemius flap.
The patient had no early post-operative complications. Unfortunately, a Glioma-Associated Oncogene Homolog 1 (GLI-1) mutation was identified in this patient one month post-operatively, which has a proliferation rate of 80 %. Thus, this patient has been referred to medical oncology at our institution and will be carefully monitored for any signs of recurrence. Despite this, the patient recovered with minimal pain throughout his recovery and had achieved 90° of knee flexion and full knee extension by ten weeks post-op. Bone bridging was evident on imaging by 6 months post-operatively, and full bone healing was observed at 9-month follow-up. At latest follow-up of 1-year post-operatively, this patient was also pain-free with full function and no signs of recurrence.
3.3 Radiographic time to union
The radiographic time to union was determined to be six months for both patients, and was confirmed with clinical examination (Fig. 1).

4 Discussion
The current case series reports successful outcomes for two patients after CarboFix CFR-PEEK plating and nailing for intercalary resection with tibial allograft.
The time to union observed in this current case series suggests that CFR-PEEK implants may provide a faster time to union than traditional implants for allograft reconstruction. Larger cohort studies have reported than the average time to union after intercalary allograft reconstruction of the lower extremity is around 11–12 months with traditional intramedullary nailing and plating.9,10 Specifically, Liu et al.9 utilized an intramedullary nail and plate combination in 10 patients, a double plate in 5, and an intramedullary nail in 2 patients, and found that the average time to union was 12.1 months (range: 6–22 months) across all 17 patients. Similarly, Misaghi et al.10 used compression plating for 16 pediatric patients and an intramedullary nail with plating for 1 pediatric patient, finding that the average time to union was 11 ± 4 months overall. In contrast, both patients in this case series had radiographic time to union confirmed with clinical examination of 6 months. The faster time to union observed may be due to the CFR-PEEK implants having a modulus of elasticity similar to cortical bone.19,20 Thus, utilization of CFR-PEEK implants for may decrease the time to union, allowing for fewer post-operative complications and quicker improvements in functional outcomes.
CFR-PEEK implants have been clinically shown to be comparable or superior to traditional stainless-steel plating and nailing implants in orthopedic trauma treatment of ankle and distal radius fractures.14,16 Guzzini et al.14 prospectively compared clinical and radiographic outcomes between 47 ankle fracture patients who received CFR-PEEK plates and 41 ankle fracture patients who received traditional stainless steel plates. There were no differences in range of clinical or radiographic outcomes at 6-, 12-, or 24-month follow-up between groups.14 Similarly, Perugia et al.16 performed a randomized controlled trial comparing clinical and radiographic outcomes between 15 distal radius fracture patients who received a CFR-PEEK volar locking plate and 15 patients who received a titanium volar locking plate. At a mean of 1-year follow-up, all clinical and radiographic outcomes were similar between groups.16 Overall, these studies show that using CFR-PEEK plates is safe and comparable to standard of care for the treatment of ankle and wrist fractures.
In vitro laboratory studies have also found that CFR-PEEK implants are either comparable or superior to traditional implant options.21–23 Thorough biomechanical testing of a tibial 10 mm nail, a dynamic compression plate, a proximal humeral plate, and a distal volar radial plate, all made of Piccolo CFR-PEEK Optima, found that all implants were comparable to three commercially-available counterparts.21 When biomechanically testing the CFR-PEEK CarboClear Pedicle Screw System (CarboFix Orthopedics Ltd., Israel) used in spine surgery, it was found that the CFR-PEEK system had similar mechanical properties, with superior fatigue properties, compared to commonly used titanium systems.22 Several factors contribute to the potential benefit of CFR-PEEK implants, such as: the fatigue resistance,22 a modulus of elasticity and tensile strength similar to cortical bone,19,20 minimal radiotherapy dose perturbation effects which are superior to metal implants,24 and the reduction in CT/MRI artifact during post-operative imaging.23
A previous study by the Italian Orthopaedic Society Bone Metastasis Study Group presented post-operative outcomes for a cohort of 53 adult oncology patients who received CFR-PEEK nailing.18 These patients underwent CFR-PEEK nailing of the humerus (n = 35), femur (n = 11) and tibia (n = 7) for fixation after either primary sarcoma excision or pathological fractures from bone metastases.18 Of the 7 tibial patients, five were experiencing pathological fractures from bone metastases of the uterus, breast, or lung, while the other two patients had a primary myeloma and a primary undifferentiated carcinoma.18 Post-operative outcomes for tibial patients were not available as outcomes were not differentiated between anatomic region treated, however across the whole study cohort, CFR-PEEK implants did not affect adjuvant procedures.18 Also, the implants led to no complications or adverse events, and besides one screw loosening, no other loosening or hardware breakage were observed in these patients.18 Future studies providing sub-analyses based on body region, as well as primary sarcoma vs. pathological bone metastasis fractures, will be valuable to optimize surgical indications and patient care.
There is currently no consensus regarding the surgical technique and implants utilized for intercalary allograft reconstruction.3 Ugur et al.3 surveyed 126 physician members of the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS), presenting two clinical scenarios and asking the physicians their preferred allograft type, compression and fixation approach, and additional techniques used. While most surgeons preferred plate(s) and screw fixation, the number and type of plates, as well as the number, type, and location of screws, were inconsistent.3 The variability in preference highlights a lack of comparative studies evaluating intra-operative techniques and different types of implants in the orthopedic oncology literature. Future comparative studies and randomized controlled trials will be helpful for optimizing the intercalary allograft reconstruction technique.
4.1 Clinical recommendations
If possible and feasible, CFR-PEEK implants should be included in future comparative studies due to their advantageous biomechanical properties, minimal radiotherapy dosage perturbations, and reduction in post-operative imaging artifacts. Until then, orthopedic oncology surgeons may consider using CFR-PEEK implants in their patients, however a strong recommendation cannot yet be provided without more substantial research.
4.2 Study limitations
There are significant limitations to this study. First, only two patients were evaluated in this case series. Larger studies of CarboFix CFR-PEEK implants are necessary; however, this case series is the first to isolate outcomes in oncologic patients who underwent intercalary resection with tibial allograft reconstruction. Also, this study is non-comparative, so no clear clinical recommendations can be made. Plus, time to union was assessed at standard-of-care follow-up intervals only, so the true time to union time likely occurred between two follow-up time points. Finally, a minimum of 1-year follow-up was implemented, however longer-term outcomes will clarify any advantages and disadvantages of CFR-PEEK implants.
5 Conclusion
Both patients who received CarboFix CFR-PEEK plating and nailing for intercalary resection with tibial allograft had a successful surgical recovery with no post-operative complications. CarboFix CFR-PEEK implants may be safe and effective for intercalary resection with tibial allograft, however future larger comparative studies are needed.
Author contribution
Both authors contributed to the study idea and study design. The first author performed patient screening and data collection. The second author evaluated radiographic imaging. Both authors wrote, edited, and approved the final manuscript.
Sources of funding/scholarship
n/A.
References
- Limb salvage versus amputation in patients with osteosarcoma of the extremities: an update in the modern era using the National Cancer Database. BMC Cancer. 2020;20(1):995.
- [Google Scholar]
- Clinical and functional outcomes of tibial intercalary allografts after tumor resection. Orthopedics. 2012;35(3):e391-e396.
- [Google Scholar]
- Variability in the reported surgical techniques and methods for intercalary reconstruction following tumor resection. Surg Oncol. 2021;38
- [Google Scholar]
- Intercalary allograft reconstructions following resection of primary bone tumors: a nationwide multicenter study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2014;96(4):e26.
- [Google Scholar]
- Intercalary reconstructions after bone tumor resections: a review of treatments. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2017;27(6):737-746.
- [Google Scholar]
- Do massive allograft reconstructions for tumors of the femur and tibia survive 10 or more years after implantation? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020;478(3):517-524.
- [Google Scholar]
- Intercalary allograft to reconstruct large-segment diaphysis defects after resection of lower extremity malignant bone tumor. Cancer Manag Res. 2020;12:4299-4308.
- [Google Scholar]
- Intercalary allograft reconstruction of the proximal tibia with and without a free fibula flap in pediatric patients. J Pediatr Orthop. 2020;40(9):e833-e838.
- [Google Scholar]
- Biological intercalary reconstruction with bone grafts after joint-sparing resection of the lower limb: is this an effective and durable solution for joint preservation? Surg Technol Int. 2018;32
- [Google Scholar]
- Intercalary femur and tibia segmental allografts provide an acceptable alternative in reconstructing tumor resections. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2004;426:97-102.
- [Google Scholar]
- The invisible nail: a technique report of treatment of a pathological humerus fracture with a radiolucent intramedullary nail. Injury. 2011;42(4):424-426.
- [Google Scholar]
- Comparison between carbon-peek plate and conventional stainless steal plate in ankle fractures. A prospective study of two years follow up. Injury. 2017;48(6):1249-1252.
- [Google Scholar]
- Preliminary experience with triangular CarboFix “Piccolo” Distal Radius Plate in wrist fractures. Clinical and radiological results. Acta Biomed. 2018;90(1-S):61-66.
- [Google Scholar]
- Comparison between Carbon-Peek volar locking plates and titanium volar locking plates in the treatment of distal radius fractures. Injury. 2017;48(Suppl 3):S24-S29.
- [Google Scholar]
- The CarbofixTM “Piccolo Proximal femur nail”: a new perspective for treating proximal femur lesion. A technique report. J Orthop. 2016;13(4):343-346.
- [Google Scholar]
- Carbon-fiber reinforced intramedullary nailing in musculoskeletal tumor surgery: a national multicentric experience of the Italian Orthopaedic Society (SIOT) Bone Metastasis Study Group. Injury. 2017;48:S55-S59.
- [Google Scholar]
- Applications of polyetheretherketone (PEEK) in oral implantology and prosthodontics. J Prosthodont Res. 2016;60(1):12-19.
- [Google Scholar]
- Review on development and dental applications of polyetheretherketone-based biomaterials and restorations. Materials. 2021;14(2):408.
- [Google Scholar]
- Carbon fiber reinforced PEEK Optima--a composite material biomechanical properties and wear/debris characteristics of CF-PEEK composites for orthopedic trauma implants. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. 2013;17:221-228.
- [Google Scholar]
- A novel spine fixation system made entirely of carbon-fiber-reinforced PEEK composite: an in vitro mechanical evaluation. Adv Orthop. 2020;2020
- [Google Scholar]
- Carbon fiber intramedullary nails reduce artifact in postoperative advanced imaging. Skeletal Radiol. 2015;44(9):1317-1325.
- [Google Scholar]
- The prospect of carbon fiber implants in radiotherapy. J Appl Clin Med Phys. 2012;13(4):152-159.
- [Google Scholar]

