Non-surgical interventions for isolated Salter-Harris type I distal fibula fractures: A systematic review
Article History
-
Received: ,
Accepted: ,
Abstract
Abstract
Salter-Harris Type I (SH1) fractures of the distal fibula are inherently stable and can be managed conservatively with immobilisation. Numerous immobilisation techniques are used in clinical practice, with no gold standard currently established. This systematic review aims to evaluate the functional and patient-reported outcomes of traditional, rigid immobilisation techniques compared to less restrictive ones that allow earlier mobilisation.
The PubMed, MEDLINE Ovid, Embase and Cochrane Library databases were searched systematically for studies on skeletally immature children and adolescents with isolated distal fibula SH1 fractures. Those with polytrauma or pre-existing musculoskeletal or developmental conditions were excluded. Quality assessment was conducted using Cochrane risk-of-bias and JBI tools. Narrative analysis was employed in conjunction with Synthesis Without Meta-analysis (SWiM).
Six studies involving 349 participants were included, of which four were randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and two were observational studies. Within the RCT group, three compared casting to bracing, tubular bandaging or controlled ankle motion (CAM) boot wearing, while one compared posterior splinting to bracing. Both observational studies only reported outcomes of one immobilisation technique – one on casting and the other on bracing. Nine outcomes were reported, with less restrictive immobilisation having more favourable results in six – time to return to normal levels of activity, functional scores, satisfaction, complications, cost-effectiveness and hours of school missed. The remaining three outcomes – pain, duration of analgesia and weight-bearing – were comparable in both immobilisation groups.
Collectively, the findings underscore the adequacy and benefits of using less restrictive immobilisation for SH1 distal fibula fractures, which is in keeping with the current trend towards less rigid immobilisation techniques in clinical practice. Limitations of this review include reporting biases and lack of certainty of evidence from small sample sizes.
II.
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1 Introduction
Paediatric ankle physeal fractures account for the largest proportion of growth plate injuries of the lower limbs.1 These fractures can be classified using the Salter-Harris classification, in which Salter-Harris Type I (SH1) fractures are transverse fractures of the physis, separating the metaphysis from the epiphysis.2 Such fractures of the distal fibula are usually inherently stable, and can be managed conservatively with protective immobilisation.3 Immobilisation of fractures allows for stability, which in turn facilitates the differentiation of osteoprogenitor stem cells into osteoblasts for bone tissue regeneration.4 Various methods of immobilisation are available, including ankle braces, splints, rigid casts and controlled ankle motion (CAM) boots.5
Given the variety of protective immobilisation modalities, exploring the differences in effectiveness would help to guide healthcare professionals in their choice of immobilisation in the management of isolated SH1 distal fibula fractures. Existing evidence has been equivocal in terms of a gold standard method of immobilisation. A systematic review done by Yeung et al. published in 2016 comparing three studies found no significant differences in functional outcomes between patients treated with braces compared to casts, although evidence of the three studies included were noted to be of “low quality”.5 This is corroborated by another systematic review evaluating the quality of literature on the diagnosis, treatment and outcomes of such fractures.6 As a result, there has been notable variability in the choice of immobilisation modality instituted.7,8
This systematic review aims to evaluate the outcomes of different immobilisation techniques used to manage isolated SH1 distal fibula fractures and offer more comprehensive and updated research of primary studies in this field. In particular, it will compare the outcomes of casting or posterior splinting, which are more traditional and rigid immobilisation techniques, with newer techniques that generally allow for earlier mobilisation8–10 such as bracing, tubular bandaging, or CAM boot wearing. It is hypothesised that less restrictive methods of immobilisation have comparable, if not better functional outcomes four weeks post-injury. Other outcomes such as patient satisfaction and treatment-related complications will also be explored.
2 Methods
The systematic review was carried out in accordance to the 2020 Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines11 and a protocol was registered on the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) (ID CRD42023450530).
2.1 Eligibility criteria
Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and other observational study designs were included in data extraction and analysis. No restrictions were placed on publication date or language to ensure comprehensiveness. However, opinion pieces, editorials and articles were deemed to have sufficiently high risks of bias and were excluded during study selection.
Skeletally immature children and adolescents who had sustained an isolated and closed SH1 distal fibula fracture were included. Participants with the following were excluded:⁃fused fibular growth plate⁃Salter-Harris II fractures and above⁃polytrauma⁃musculoskeletal or developmental conditions that might impede normal fracture healing.
2.2 Search strategy and information sources
Search strategies were developed for the databases of PubMed, MEDLINE Ovid, Embase and Cochrane Library in consultation with a medical librarian (details in Appendix A). Systematic searches of the databases were carried out in August 2023. Additional sources of information were retrieved from Google Scholar.
2.3 Study selection and data extraction
Studies were imported either into Covidence, an online systematic review software, or into a reference manager utilised together with Microsoft Excel. They were then selected in accordance to the 2020 PRISMA Flow Diagram. Duplicate searches were first removed. Next, studies were screened based on their titles and abstracts. Remaining studies then underwent a full-text review to determine their relevance. Finally, data was extracted from shortlisted studies using a standardised template (Appendix B) with the aid of the Covidence software. Data items extracted included:⁃general information including publication date and country of origin⁃patient demographics including age and sample size⁃details of the interventions such as duration and weight-bearing status⁃outcomes such as scoring systems or complications of treatment.
Throughout the whole process, studies were screened independently by four reviewers. Any discrepancies or differences in opinions were discussed and resolved.
2.4 Quality assessment
The quality of shortlisted studies was assessed independently by four reviewers. For RCTs, the revised Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for randomised trials (RoB 2) was utilised to assess for bias across five domains, namely the randomisation process, deviations from intended interventions, missing outcome data, measurement of outcomes and selection of reported results.12 Quality assessment for observational studies was carried out using various critical appraisal tools from JBI based on their respective study designs.13–15
2.5 Synthesis of results
High levels of methodological heterogeneity from various study designs and clinical diversity of outcomes reported by each study contraindicated meta-analysis. Narrative analysis was employed in conjunction with the Synthesis Without Meta-analysis (SWiM) reporting guideline.16 Studies were grouped according to outcomes of interest and ranked according to study design and risk of bias.
Within individual studies, subjects were grouped into either the intervention group or the comparator group based on which immobilisation technique had been instituted. Those under the intervention group had been treated by either casts or posterior splints, while those under the comparator group had been treated by either braces, CAM boots, or tubular bandages.
Descriptive statistics such as mean and median values, ranges and percentages were reported. Where possible, p-values were combined by first converting two-sided values to one-sided ones, then adopting the Fisher's method for combination. Vote-counting based on direction of effect, irrespective of statistical significance, was also utilised. Extracted data were tabulated and summarised based on synthesis methods.
3 Results
3.1 Study selection
A total of 73 records were identified across four databases (Table 1), while two records were obtained through citation searching on Google Scholar. After removing 14 duplicates and excluding 48 records based on title and abstract screening, 13 full text reports were retrieved. A further six reports were excluded based on exclusion criteria. For instance, a cohort study by Cant et al. investigating the incidence of physeal fractures17 was excluded by virtue of irrelevant outcome while an expert commentary by Dowling et al. was excluded by virtue of ineffectual study design.18 Ultimately, seven studies were shortlisted.7,9,10,19–22 A detailed breakdown of the identification and screening process is summarised in Fig. 1.
| Database | Date of search | Number of search results |
| PubMed | 2/8/2023 | 32 |
| Ovid MEDLINE | 2/8/2023 | 6 |
| Embase | 3/8/2023 | 33 |
| Cochrane Library | 3/8/2023 | 2 |

3.2 Quality assessment results
All RCTs included were classified as having “some concerns” (Table 2) due to risk of bias arising from deviation from intended interventions because it was not feasible to blind children and the personnel who instituted immobilisation treatment to them. Some discrepancies and lack of information were noted to be present in the randomisation process in addition to some missing outcome reporting by Gleeson et al. (1996). Nonetheless, most studies were deemed to have low risk of bias in the domains of randomisation processes as well as outcome and result processing (details in Appendix C). No domains were deemed to be at high risk of bias in all four studies.
| Beck et al. (2023) | Barnett et al. (2012) | Boutis et al. (2007) | Gleeson et al. (1996) | |
| Randomisation process | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Some concerns |
| Deviations from intended interventions | Some concerns | Some concerns | Some concerns | Some concerns |
| Missing outcome data | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Some concerns |
| Measurement of outcome | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk |
| Selection of reported result | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk | Low risk |
| Overall risk of bias | Some concerns | Some concerns | Some concerns | Some concerns |
Two observational studies were found to be of adequate quality to be included. The prospective cohort study by Boutis et al. (2016) was found to have valid and reliable evaluation methods for SH1 fractures and outcomes, with appropriate statistical analysis. The case series by Sankar et al. (2008) used validated methods to diagnose SH1 fractures and had clear inclusion criteria and reported outcomes. The third study, a cross-sectional prevalence study by Beck et al. (2022), was excluded from analysis due to low response rates and the lack of validated methods to identify and measure ankle injuries.
3.3 Characteristics of included studies
Four of the studies included were RCTs while two were observational studies, one being a cohort study and the other, a case series. Three RCTs compared casting to other removable methods of immobilisation such as bracing and CAM boot wearing while one compared the use of a backslab (posterior splint) to a brace. Both observational studies only reported outcomes of one immobilisation technique, one on a cast and the other on a removable brace. All studies had at least one subgroup of participants that fit into the inclusion and exclusion criteria of this review.
Three studies – Beck et al. (2023), Barnett et al. (2012) and Boutis et al. (2007) – included other low-risk ankle injuries such as avulsion fractures in their study populations, with only Barnett et al. (2012) reporting subgroup analyses for isolated SH1 distal fibula fractures. A detailed breakdown of study characteristics can be found in Table 3.
| Study design | Population | Aim | Size | Country | |
| Beck et al. (2023) | Randomised Controlled Trial | Skeletally immature patients aged 5 to 16 years with negative ankle x-rays and/or a diagnosis of an isolated low-risk ankle fracture (nondisplaced SH1 distal fibula fracture or nondisplaced distal fibula avulsion fracture) seen within the first 7 days after injury | To determine differences in various outcomes between CAM boots and casts in low-energy lateral ankle injuries in paediatric patients | 55 | USA |
| Barnett et al. (2012) | Children aged 5 to 15 years with a clinical diagnosis of a low-risk ankle fracture (definition of “low-risk ankle fracture” - an avulsion fracture of the distal fibula, a nondisplaced SH1 or SH2 fracture of the fibula, or an avulsion fracture of the lateral talus)Subgroup analyses for SH1 fractures available | To compare the below-knee fibreglass backslab (posterior splint) to the Air-Stirrup ankle brace | 33 | Australia | |
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Children between 5 and 18 years of age who presented with an acute, symptomatic, low-risk ankle fracture within 72 h after injury (definition of “low-risk ankle fracture” – nondisplaced distal fibular SH1 and SH2 fractures and avulsion fractures of the distal fibula or fibular epiphysis) | To compare removable ankle braces with conventional rigid cast immobilisation in terms of recovery of physical function and cost-effectiveness | 75 | Canada | |
| Gleeson et al. (1996) | Children who had swelling and tenderness over the lateral malleolus, a normal ankle radiograph with no evidence of growth-plate fusion, and who were unable to/could only partially bear weight | To compare either immobilisation in plaster of Paris or the use of supportive bandage and crutches | 45 | UK | |
| Boutis et al. (2016) | Prospective cohort study | Children aged 5 to 12 years who presented with an isolated lateral ankle injury and were clinically presumed to have SH1 fracture of the distal fibula (“clinically presumed SH1DF” - limited weight-bearing, tenderness and swelling over the lateral aspect of the distal fibula at the level of the physis, 3 radiographic views of the ankle demonstrating open physes and the absence of a fracture) | Primary: to determine the frequency of true SH1DF in children using MRISecondary: to compare the functional recovery of children with fractures identified by MRI vs those with ligament injuries when uniformly treated with a removable brace | 135 | Canada |
| Sankar et al. (2008) | Case series | Children with open physes around the ankle, isolated injury, point tenderness over the distal fibula, and no evidence of osseous injury on initial plain radiographs | To determine the incidence of occult fracture in children with an acute ankle injuries | 6 | USA |
3.4 Synthesis of outcomes
Across the six studies, a total of 349 children and adolescents with isolated distal fibula fractures were sampled. Nine outcomes with regard to the management of such fractures were reported and grouped into primary functional outcomes and secondary or ancillary outcomes (Table 4).
| Study | Primary/functional outcomes | Secondary/ancillary outcomes |
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Time to return to normal activities | Satisfaction with immobilisation |
| Pain | Treatment-related complications | |
| Weight-bearing status | Cost-effectiveness | |
| Modified ASKp score | ||
| Beck et al. (2023) | Pain | Satisfaction with immobilisation |
| Oxford Foot & Ankle questionnaire | Treatment-related complications | |
| Hours of school missed | ||
| Barnett et al. (2012) | Time to return to normal activities | Treatment-related complications |
| Weight-bearing status | Duration of analgesia | |
| Modified ASKp score | ||
| Gleeson et al. (1996) | Time to return to normal activities | – |
| Functional assessment score (unvalidated) | ||
| Sankar et al. (2008) | Time to return to normal activities | – |
| Boutis et al. (2016) | Time to return to normal activities | – |
3.4.1 Primary outcomes
Descriptive statistics ranging from percentages in dichotomous measures to mean and median values and ranges in continuous measures were used across studies (Table 5).
| Study | Primary outcome | Intervention groups | Comparator groups | Other comments |
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Time to return to normal levels of activity | % return after 4 weeks | p = 0.038 favouring comparator | |
| 59.5 | 80.8 | |||
| Barnett et al. (2012) | Median days (IQR) | – | ||
| 20 (15.5–23) | 12.5 (8–17.5) | |||
| Gleeson et al. (1996) | Mean days | P = 0.0002 favouring comparator | ||
| 20.19 | 14.17 | |||
| Sankar et al. (2008) | Mean days (range) | – | ||
| 25 (12–34) | – | |||
| Boutis et al. (2016) | % return after 1 month | – | ||
| – | 100 | |||
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Pain (face scale) | Mean score (SD) after 4 weeks | Not statistically significant (p = 0.930) | |
| 0.33 (0.13) | 0.32 (0.10) | |||
| Beck et al. (2023) | Mean score (SD) after 4 weeks | Not statistically significant | ||
| 0.32 | 0.41 | |||
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Weight-bearing status | % weight-bearing after 4 weeks | Not statistically significant (p = 0.820) | |
| 78 | 75 | |||
| Barnett et al. (2012) | % weight-bearing (range) after 4 weeks | – | ||
| 88 (65.1–97.1) | 95 (78–99) | |||
| Boutis et al. (2016) | % weight-bearing after 4 weeks | – | ||
| – | 100 | |||
The time taken to return to normal levels of activity of 294 children and adolescents were studied, and in 120 of these patients, time taken was significantly shorter when they were immobilised with less rigid methods as compared to casting (p-values <0.05). An additional 33 were shown to have a lower median time taken when put in a brace instead of a backslab. Remaining participants either had no statistical difference in times or were not compared statistically.
Amongst the 130 children and adolescents who rated their pain four weeks post-injury on a pain face scale, no significant differences (p-value >0.05) were found between those who underwent casting versus those with less rigid immobilisation techniques. Likewise in 243 children and adolescents who had their weight-bearing status evaluated, no significant difference (p-value >0.05) was noted between both groups.
3.4.2 Statistical combination of p-values
The standard metric of a combined p-value was used for two outcomes – functional scores and patient satisfaction. Within the former, a variety of scoring systems was adopted across studies, with Boutis et al. (2007) and Barnet et al. (2012) using the modified ASKp score, Beck et al. (2023) using the Oxford Foot and Ankle questionnaire, and Gleeson et al. (1996) using a self-devised, unvalidated score consisting of pain, tenderness, and weight-bearing status. For the two studies that reported the latter outcome, there was minimal information beyond p-values, making this synthesis method appropriate.
There was statistically significant evidence that less rigid, more easily removable immobilisation devices performed better both in terms of functional scoring (combined p < 0.0001, 4 studies) as well as patient satisfaction (combined p < 0.0001, 2 studies) when compared to more rigid casts or posterior splints (Table 6).
| Study | Outcome | Available data | 1-sided p-value (derived) |
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Functional scores at 4 weeks | Modified ASKp score: | 5x10−5 |
| Intervention score at 4 weeks 85.3; | |||
| Comparator score at 4 weeks 91.3 | |||
| Favours comparator (brace) | |||
| 2-sided p < 0.0001, n = 104 | |||
| Beck et al. (2023) | Oxford score for difficulty running at 4 weeks | 0.0055 | |
| Favours comparator (CAM boot) | |||
| 2-sided p = 0.011 | |||
| Oxford score for leg ache/soreness at 4 weeks | 0.025 | ||
| Favours comparator (CAM boot) | |||
| 2-sided p < 0.005 | |||
| Barnett et al. (2012) | Modified ASKp score: | 0.13 | |
| Intervention at 4 weeks 93.8; | |||
| Comparator score at 4 weeks 90.2 | |||
| Not statistically significant | |||
| 2-sided p = 0.26 | |||
| Gleeson et al. (1996) | Non-validated self-devised score | – | |
| Not statistically significant | |||
| χ2 = 41.7Combined p-value (Fisher's method) = 8.48x10−6 (<0.0001) | |||
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Satisfaction with immobilisation device | Favours comparator (brace) | 5x10−5 |
| 2-sided p < 0.0001, n = 104 | |||
| Beck et al. (2023) | Intervention score at 4 weeks 4.25; | 0.025 | |
| Comparator score at 4 weeks 5.26 | |||
| Favours comparator (CAM boot) | |||
| 2-sided p < 0.05, n = 56 | |||
| χ2 = 27.2Combined p-value (Fisher's method) = 1.81x10−5 (<0.0001) | |||
3.4.3 Vote-counting based on direction of effect
Outcomes synthesised using vote-counting included treatment-related complications, which had inconsistent effect measures reported across included studies, and other remaining outcomes only reported in single studies with only direction of effect described, such as cost-effectiveness, hours of school missed and duration of analgesia. Of the reported treatment-related complications, skin-related complications such as pressure marks and blisters were the most common, accounting for 20 of 41 cases in the intervention group who had been treated with either casts or posterior splints, and three of six cases in the comparator group who had been treated with either braces or CAM boots. Functional and device-related complications such as ankle stiffness, range of motion issues, broken or wet casts and heel pain accounted for the remainder of cases.
For each study, complications of comparators were categorised as either less harmful (vote count = 1) or more harmful (vote count = 0) vis-à-vis those of interventions, while other effects were categorised as either beneficial (vote count = 1) or harmful (vote count = 0). Statistical significance was not factored in as underpowered studies might not be counted accurately, in turn leading to inaccurate conclusions.23
All three studies (100%) reporting treatment-related complications favoured bracing or CAM boot wearing over casting or splinting, while two of three studies (67%) favoured these modalities in terms of other secondary outcomes described in Table 7.
| Study | Outcome | Available data | Vote count |
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Treatment-related complications | Intervention (cast) 32% unscheduled visitsComparator (brace) 7.4% unscheduled visits | 1 |
| Beck et al. (2023) | Intervention (cast) 15 of 28 (53.5%) complications after 4 weeksComparator (brace) 1 of 27 (3%) complications after 4 weeksStatistically significant difference (p < 0.0001) | 1 | |
| Barnett et al. (2012) | Intervention (posterior splint) 13 of 23 complications (56.5%)Comparator (brace) 5 of 22 (22.7%) | 1 | |
| % of studies favouring comparator (brace or CAM boot) over intervention (cast or splint): 100% (3 of 3) | |||
| Boutis et al. (2007) | Cost-effectiveness | Favours comparator (brace)Statistically significant, p < 0.0001 | 1 |
| Beck et al. (2023) | Hours of school missed (hours) | Not statistically significant (intervention 3.82, comparator 3.73) | 1 |
| Barnett et al. (2012) | Duration of analgesia (days) | Intervention 1.5 (mean), 1–4 (inter-quartile range)Comparator 2 (mean), 0–6 (interquartile range) | 0 |
| % of studies favouring comparator (brace or CAM boot) over intervention (cast or splint): 67% (2 of 3) | |||
4 Discussion
Collectively, the findings of this systematic review underscore the adequacy and benefits of using less restrictive immobilisation for the treatment of SH1 distal fibula fractures. Of the nine outcomes reported, the comparator group of immobilisation techniques comprising braces, CAM boots and tubular bandaging had more favourable results in six and was comparable to the intervention group in the remaining three (Fig. 2).

An analysis of primary functional outcomes demonstrated a substantial advantage of the comparator group in an earlier return to regular levels of activity, which was also reflected in significantly better functional scores at 4 weeks post-injury. This may be explained by the more flexible removal timings of these immobilisation devices and consequently an earlier return to mobilisation and weightbearing, which promotes fracture healing through functional loading.24,25 In Boutis et al. (2007), Beck et al. (2023) and Gleeson et al. (1996), comparator groups were encouraged to remove their devices to bear weight as tolerated or for range of motion exercises, whereas rigid casts could only be removed between two to three weeks post-injury. Not surprisingly, higher flexibility associated with less restrictive methods also manifested in better ancillary outcomes such as higher satisfaction scores and lower incidences of treatment-related complications.
The three outcomes for which results were comparable between intervention and comparator groups – pain, weight-bearing status and duration of analgesia required – were all acute outcomes. Given that isolated SH1 distal fibula fractures generally have short recovery times,3 it is reasonable to extrapolate that children and adolescents would have almost no pain and difficulty weightbearing at 4 weeks since these would be one of the first to resolve before the return of residual function. The low rate and mildness of complications reported align with the inherent stability and good prognosis of SH1 fractures. Adverse outcomes such as fracture malunion or growth arrest were not reported in any study.
Traditionally, the diagnosis of a SH1 distal fibula fracture has been one of exclusion. Skeletally immature ankles with no evidence of a fracture on plain radiographs but with maximal tenderness over the fibular growth plate are classified as such,3,21 owing to conventional wisdom that the epiphyseal cartilage is weaker than surrounding ligaments, making such a presentation more likely to be a physeal fracture instead of a ligamentous injury.26 Such a method of classification of SH1 distal fibula fractures was adopted in four of the six studies analysed in this review. However, recent evidence has challenged this theory, with further modes of imaging such as MRI and ultrasound concluding that a gross majority of these injuries are in fact ligamentous injuries, hence suggesting that SH1 distal fibula fractures are over-diagnosed.7,20–22,27,28 Routine casting of these injuries is thus a potential over-treatment7 as it is more restrictive for mobility.9
In keeping with this evidence is a trend towards less rigid immobilisation techniques in clinical practice for children and adolescents presenting with the abovementioned ankle injuries. A 2022 survey by Beck et al. found that the CAM boot has overtaken traditional casting as the most popular immobilisation technique for SH1 distal fibula fractures amongst orthopaedic surgeons in North America, and that younger doctors are more likely to prefer the CAM boot over casting.7 Moreover, Boutis et al. (2016) has found no differences in functional outcomes post-injury between fractures and ligamentous injuries when both were treated with a removable brace.21 As such, this review advocates for the use of less restrictive immobilisation with weight-bearing as tolerated, be it for SH1 distal fibula fractures or ligamentous injuries.
4.1 Limitations
Reporting biases could have arisen during results synthesis as the relative sizes of studies and the magnitude of outcomes analysed were not taken into consideration by the standard metrics utilised.
Additionally, heterogeneities in patient populations exist in Boutis et al. (2007) and Beck et al. (2023) as analyses did not separate SH1 fractures from other low risk ankle injuries studied, thus influencing outcomes.
Finally, in an effort to interpret all outcomes reported using a variety of synthesis methods, certainty of evidence could also have been affected owing to small sample sizes as well as the small number of studies reporting each individual outcome.
5 Conclusion
Less restrictive methods of immobilisation such as braces and CAM walkers that allow early mobilisation are sufficient when treating isolated SHI distal fibula fractures and may even have better functional and patient-centred outcomes compared to rigid casts.
Ethical statement
The authors declare that the study was performed under the guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki. The ethics board approval is required as this is a systematic review. All data has been deidentified.
Funding statement
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Consent
No case details or other personal information or images of patients and any other individuals were included in this systematic review. As such, no formal consent was required.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
J.Y. Tay: Conceptualization, Methodology, Validation, Investigation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing, Visualization, Project administration. Nicole K.L. Lee: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing, Visualization. Andrew C.C. Chou: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing, Visualization. M.A. Zainuddin: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing, Visualization. Arjandas Mahadev: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – review & editing, Visualization. Kenneth P.L. Wong: Conceptualization, Methodology, Validation, Investigation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing, Visualization, Project administration.
References
- Pediatric ankle fractures: concepts and treatment principles. Foot Ankle Clin. 2015 Dec;20(4):705-719.
- [Google Scholar]
- Classifications in brief: salter-harris classification of pediatric physeal fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2016 Nov;474(11):2531-2537.
- [Google Scholar]
- Physeal fractures of the distal tibia and fibula (Salter-Harris Type I, II, III, and IV fractures) J Pediatr Orthop. 2012 Jun;32(Suppl 1):S62-S68.
- [Google Scholar]
- Fracture healing: mechanisms and interventions. Nat Rev Rheumatol. 2015 Jan;11(1):45-54.
- [Google Scholar]
- Interventions for treating ankle fractures in children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016 Apr;4(4):CD010836.
- [Google Scholar]
- Low energy, lateral ankle injuries in pediatric and adolescent patients: a systematic review of ankle sprains and nondisplaced distal fibula fractures. J Pediatr Orthop. 2020 Jul;40(6):283-287.
- [Google Scholar]
- Treatment variability and complications associated with pediatric lateral ankle injuries: a posna quality, safety, and value initiative survey. Orthop J Sport Med. 2022 Jun;10(6)
- [Google Scholar]
- Evidence into practice: emergency physician management of common pediatric fractures. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2014 Jul;30(7):462-468.
- [Google Scholar]
- A randomized, controlled trial of a removable brace versus casting in children with low-risk ankle fractures. Pediatrics. 2007 Jun 1;119(6):e1256-e1263.
- [Google Scholar]
- Functional outcome after air-stirrup ankle brace or fiberglass backslab for pediatric low-risk ankle fractures: a randomized observer-blinded controlled trial. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2012 Aug;28(8):745-749.
- [Google Scholar]
- The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 2021:372.
- [Google Scholar]
- RoB 2: a revised tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ. 2019 Aug;366:l4898.
- [Google Scholar]
- Methodological guidance for systematic reviews of observational epidemiological studies reporting prevalence and incidence data. Int J Evid Base Healthc. 2015;13(3):147-153.
- [Google Scholar]
- Synthesis without meta-analysis (SWiM) in systematic reviews: reporting guideline. BMJ. 2020 Jan;368:l6890.
- [Google Scholar]
- The incidence of physeal fractures in the lower limb and the frequency of premature physeal closure: a cohort study of 236 patients. Acta Orthop. 2023 Jun;94:289-294.
- [Google Scholar]
- Interventions for treating low-risk ankle fractures in children. Paediatr Child Health. 2017 Oct;22(7):393-394.
- [Google Scholar]
- Controlled ankle movement (CAM) boot provides improved outcomes with lower complications than short leg walking cast in low-energy pediatric lateral ankle injuries: a prospective, randomized study. J Pediatr Orthop. 2023 Aug;43(7):418-423.
- [Google Scholar]
- Ultrasound assessment and conservative management of inversion injuries of the ankle in children: plaster of Paris versus Tubigrip. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1996 May;78(3):484-487.
- [Google Scholar]
- Radiograph-negative lateral ankle injuries in children: occult growth plate fracture or sprain? JAMA Pediatr. 2016 Jan;170(1)
- [Google Scholar]
- Incidence of occult fracture in children with acute ankle injuries. J Pediatr Orthop. 2008;28(5):500-501.
- [Google Scholar]
- The safety and effectiveness of early, progressive weight bearing and implant choice after traumatic lower extremity fracture: a systematic review. Bioeng (Basel, Switzerland). 2022 Dec;9(12)
- [Google Scholar]
- Mechanics and mechano-biology of fracture healing in normal and osteoporotic bone. Osteoporos Int a J Establ as result Coop between Eur Found Osteoporos Natl Osteoporos Found USA. 2005 Mar;16(Suppl 2):S36-S43.
- [Google Scholar]
- Magnetic resonance imaging of clinically suspected Salter-Harris I fracture of the distal fibula. Injury. 2010 Aug;41(8):852-856.
- [Google Scholar]
- Acute paediatric ankle trauma: MRI versus plain radiography. Skeletal Radiol. 2001 Sep;30(9):504-511.
- [Google Scholar]
