Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories
Case Report
Clinical Images
Research Article
Review Article
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories
Case Report
Clinical Images
Research Article
Review Article
View/Download PDF
Case Report
2023
:2;
100117
doi:
10.1016/j.jorep.2022.100117

Translate:

Peroneal nerve palsy after hip arthroscopy with a perineal post: A case report of postless versus standard traction

Author affiliations
Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
Article History
Corresponding author(s)

∗Corresponding author: Ivan Wong. research@drivanwong.com

Article tools · PDF & citations

Abstract

Abstract

Motor neurapraxias after hip arthroscopy rarely occur, and they are mostly described with the use of traction with a perineal post. Postless hip arthroscopy is recently gaining attention due to the low traction-related complication rates, but there are no cases reporting postoperative peroneal nerve palsy between the two traction techniques so far.

A 40-year-old female weight-lifter presented with bilateral hip pain and radiographic imaging consistent with femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) syndrome and a labral tear. Bilateral hip arthroscopy was performed on a postless distraction table for the left hip and on a standard traction table with a perineal post for the right hip. Following the right-side procedure, the patient experienced groin numbness and ipsilateral foot drop, that resolved between two weeks to three months, post-operatively.

Hip arthroscopy using both traction techniques were efficient in this patient, but the standard traction was associated with transient pudendal and peroneal nerve injuries.

Keywords

  • Hip arthroscopy
  • Postless traction
  • Perineal post
  • Traction-related complications
  • Peroneal nerve palsy
Disclaimer:
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1

1 Introduction

Hip arthroscopy is an increasingly common procedure, with a 25-fold increase in surgical indications from 2006 to 2013 in the United States.1 Complications after hip arthroscopy are not uncommon, but rather underestimated.2,3 Neurologic injuries can range from transient numbness to permanent debilitating palsies.2,4 Motor neurapraxias after hip arthroscopy rarely occur, and they are mostly described with the use of traction with a perineal post.2,4 The hip is a constrained deep-seated joint and a traction force is required to subluxate the hip. Moreover, traction is required for most of the duration of the procedure for accurate portal placement and is important in treating central pathologies.

Traction-related complications can be avoided with shorter traction time, good patient positioning, and optimal traction equipment.3,5 Some risk factors are now recognized, allowing the surgeons to take preventative measures including placing a perineal post between the genitalia and the ipsilateral limb, using well-padded large perineal posts (>8–10 cm in diameter), and aiming for surgical time below 50 minutes.3,5 However, the complication rates remain high and can be up to 74%.2 Recently, postless hip arthroscopy has been getting attention due to the low traction-related complication rates.6,7 Recently, postless traction demonstrated similar postoperative pain to standard traction,8 but there are still no comparative reports evaluating motor neurapraxias after hip arthroscopy between the two traction techniques. We report a case of pudendal and peroneal nerve palsies following standard hip arthroscopy with a perineal post compared to an asymptomatic recovery after a postless arthroscopy in the contralateral hip of the same patient.

2

2 Case report

A 40-year-old female weight-lifter (height, 5 ft 9 in [175 cm]; weight, 225 pounds [102 kg]; body mass index, 33.3 kg/m2) presented with bilateral hip pain. Symptoms were similar for both sides but worse on the right. The pain was located anteriorly in the groin area, and exacerbated by hip flexion. Rotational-type maneuvers resulted in sharp pain that was rated with a severity of 8 out of 10, which had a significant effect on her gait resulting in limping and limitation in her daily life activities, including weightlifting. The symptoms resolved with rest and the patient responded partially to medications. There was no history of trauma or sudden change of activity level. Nonoperative treatment, including physical therapy and intraarticular corticosteroid injection, did not improve her symptoms.

On inspection, there was no gait abnormality, hip deformity or lower limbs malalignment. No tenderness was elicited during palpation of the osseous prominences. Range of motion of both hips was similar except for a deficit in internal rotation in the right hip compared to the left side (Table 1). The active straight leg raise test was positive on both sides and elicited a sharp pain in the groin area. The anterior impingement test was also positive on both sides. The FABER (flexion, abduction, external rotation) test was negative. Muscle strength was graded 4 over 5 on both sides for hip flexors, abductors and extensors.

Table 1 Comparison of the range of motion between the right and left hip preoperatively and at the final follow-up.
Hip motion Right hip (Post) Left hip (Postless)
Preoperative Postoperative Preoperative postoperative
Flexion 120° 124° 124° 128°
Extension 10° 10° 17° 13°
Abduction 40° 41° 52° 47°
Internal rotation 15° 40° 41° 40°
External rotation 30° 50° 59° 65°
Table 2 Comparison of the functional scores between the right and left hip preoperatively and at the final follow-up.
Outcome scale Right hip (Post) Left hip (Postless)
iHOT-33 Pre-op 11.7 68.3
Post-op 78.7 93.4
HOS-ADL Pre-op 64.1 86.1
Post-op 94.7 98.7
HOS-Sports Pre-op 12.5 37.5
Post-op 100.0 91.7
mHHS Pre-op 53.8 62.6
Post-op 95.6 90.1
NAHS Pre-op 51.3 85.0
Post-op 91.3 95.0

Imaging workup included radiographs, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) arthrogram, and computed tomography (CT) with three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction for both hips (Figs. 1–3). Both hips demonstrated similar pathology. Radiographs demonstrated an abnormal contour of the femoral head-neck junction, compatible with cam type femoroacetabular impingement (FAI). CT images showed signs of impingements on both the acetabular and femoral sides. MRI confirmed the presence of a labral tear without any chondral defects.

Preoperative radiographs showing bilateral lateral central edge angles (LCEA) on antero-posterior pelvis view (A), and an abnormal alpha angle on frog lateral view of the right hip (B).
Fig. 1 Preoperative radiographs showing bilateral lateral central edge angles (LCEA) on antero-posterior pelvis view (A), and an abnormal alpha angle on frog lateral view of the right hip (B).
Preoperative computed tomography views of the right hip showing acetabular lateral rim irregularities (black arrowhead) on the frontal view (A), and a femoral head small cyst (white arrowhead) on both sagittal and axial views (B and C).
Fig. 2 Preoperative computed tomography views of the right hip showing acetabular lateral rim irregularities (black arrowhead) on the frontal view (A), and a femoral head small cyst (white arrowhead) on both sagittal and axial views (B and C).
Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging views of the right hip showing femoral head bony edema on the coronal view (A; T2 FAT SAT), and an anterior labral tear (white arrowhead) on the sagittal view (B; T1 FAT SAT).
Fig. 3 Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging views of the right hip showing femoral head bony edema on the coronal view (A; T2 FAT SAT), and an anterior labral tear (white arrowhead) on the sagittal view (B; T1 FAT SAT).

The diagnosis of cam-type FAI with a labral tear was made and the patient elected to undergo bilateral hip arthroscopy, starting with the right side. Both surgeries were performed in the lateral decubitus position (Figs. 4–5). The right hip arthroscopy was performed using a traction system with a perineal post (Smith & Nephew®) guided by fluoroscopy. The left hip arthroscopy was performed using a postless traction system (Stryker®) guided by ultrasound for portal placement, as we previously described.9 A printed 3D model was used for preoperative planning as well as intraoperative assessment of osteoplasty. When the postless hip arthroscopy was performed, 15° of Trendelenburg was added to counteract traction and to allow for successful hip distraction. Surgical and traction times as well as traction forces as measured using a tensiometer were recorded (Table 3). In both cases, one cm of hip distraction was applied. The anterolateral and mid-anterior arthroscopic portals were established after air distension. Table 4 shows the intraoperative findings and procedures that were performed in both hips. Dynamic hip examination was performed at the end of each procedure to ensure no residual impingement persisted. Postoperative rehabilitation included the use of a hinged hip brace with flexion restricted to 90° and weight bearing as tolerated with crutches for six weeks. Progressive range of motion started at five days post-operatively.

Positioning of right hip for hip arthroscopy in lateral decubitus with a perineal post. Lateral view of the foot showing soft padding (A) used for the traction boot (B). The large perineal post is placed with the hip in abduction (D and E) then traction is obtained with forced hip adduction against the post. Final view of the positioning with full draping (F).
Fig. 4 Positioning of right hip for hip arthroscopy in lateral decubitus with a perineal post. Lateral view of the foot showing soft padding (A) used for the traction boot (B). The large perineal post is placed with the hip in abduction (D and E) then traction is obtained with forced hip adduction against the post. Final view of the positioning with full draping (F).
Positioning of left hip for hip arthroscopy in lateral decubitus with a postless system. Lateral view of the foot showing soft padding (A) used for the traction boot (B). The traction boot is connected to the traction arm (C). The table is tilted 15° of Trendelenburg and 125 lbf of traction force is used for hip distraction. (D and E) Final view of the positioning with full draping (F).
Fig. 5 Positioning of left hip for hip arthroscopy in lateral decubitus with a postless system. Lateral view of the foot showing soft padding (A) used for the traction boot (B). The traction boot is connected to the traction arm (C). The table is tilted 15° of Trendelenburg and 125 lbf of traction force is used for hip distraction. (D and E) Final view of the positioning with full draping (F).
Table 3 Traction monitoring during surgery in both hips.
Parameter Right hip (Post) Left hip (Postless)
Surgical time (min) 65 55
Traction time (mn) 32 28
Maximal traction force (lbf) na 125
Table 4 Intraoperative findings and procedures performed in both hips.
Surgical finding Surgical procedure
Right hip (Post) Left hip (Postless)
Synovitis Synovectomy Synovectomy
Labral tear Acetabular debridement and decortication followed by labral repair using 4 anchors from the 12 to 3 o'clock positions Acetabular debridement and decortication followed by labral repair using 1 anchor from the 1 to 3 o'clock positions
Chondral delamination adjacent to the labral tear No treatment No treatment
Cam lesion Osteoplasty guided by fluoroscopy from the 12 to 3 o'clock positions Osteoplasty guided by 3D module from the 12 to 3 o'clock positions
Interportal capsulotomy Capsule closure Capsule closure
3

3 Clinical findings

Following the first right hip arthroscopy, the patient experienced groin numbness and ipsilateral drop foot with reduced sensitivity over the dorsal aspect of her foot. There were no bruises over the genital area or the foot. Conversely, the left hip post-operative recovery was strictly normal with no adverse events. At the two-week post-operative follow-up, the peroneal nerve palsy completely recovered but the groin numbness persisted until three months postoperatively. Post-operative follow-up was without any further complications and the was able to return to weight-lifting at one year after the right hip arthroscopy.

4

4 FOLLOW-UP and outcomes

Patient-reported outcome scores were collected preoperatively and at the six-week, three-month, six-month and one-year post-operative timepoints to evaluate the level of patient function (Table 2).

5

5 Discussion

The main finding from this case report is that standard traction in hip arthroscopy in the lateral decubitus position can be associated with a higher risk of neurological injury, compared to a post-less traction. The patient had no prior history of knee or ankle trauma, nor a pre-existing condition for neuropathy, and there were no bruises over the genital area or the foot at the end of the procedure. Moreover, traction times in both surgeries were similar. Consequently, peroneal nerve palsy was considered mostly related to distraction neurapraxia from traction with a perineal post. This case is the first to present a postoperative motor neurapraxia in a patient who underwent bilateral/staged hip arthroscopy using the two traction techniques.

Post-operative neurapraxia after hip arthroscopy is the most common complication.4,10 These can be related to a distraction or a compression injury from the perineal post. Distraction injury typically affects the femoral and sciatic nerves while compression injury involves the groin area where the pudendal nerve is at risk.4 However, both of these injuries often coexist and most traction-related complications are mainly described with the use of a perineal post.10 In addition to neurapraxias, the use of a perineal post has been associated with perineal skin damage, scrotal/labial hematomas or necrosis and vaginal tears.6,10

The pudendal nerve is most commonly injured during hip traction. Clinical symptoms can be benign including groin numbness and pain, or on the contrary associated with serious implications including dyspareunia, erectile dysfunction, or foot drop.4,10 These are usually transient and resolve by weeks to months, but can also be long-lasting or even permanent.11 Gupta et al. evaluated complications among 6277 hip arthroscopies. The overall complication rate was 4.5%, with neurapraxia being the most common. The pudendal nerve followed by the sciatic nerve were the most injured.10 Similar findings were reported in another review of 36,761 arthroscopies which showed 3.3% overall complication rate, topped by nerve injury, mainly the pudendal and the lateral femoral cutaneous nerves.4 However, recent data suggested rates of neurapraxias after hip arthroscopy to be as high as 74% when focusing on symptoms from the patients’ perspective including skin abrasions, pressure marks, sensory disturbances, and swelling.2

The foot and ankle are less frequently involved than the groin. The most common presentations are pain or numbness.3,10 Similarly, they can be related to distraction injury of the sciatic and peroneal nerves, or to compression forces from the traction boot.2,10 Caution is advised when strapping the ankle, as malpositioning or extreme compression forces can result in ankle fractures or vascular obstruction.2,10 Our patient had normal pulses and no bruises or swelling over her foot, as well as no foot or ankle pain, which highly relates her clinical neurapraxia to a nerve distraction injury. This case showed groin numbness as well which mean the traction force associated with the use of a perineal post was significant enough to create both pudendal compression injury as well as peroneal distraction palsy. Traction force was also shown to be correlated to sciatic nerve injury during hip arthroscopy.12 Thus, the use of a perineal post to achieve adequate hip traction could be associated with a higher traction force compared to a postless traction.

Postless distraction, on the other hand, offers a safe and effective method to perform hip arthroscopy. Few studies have described clinical outcomes so far, but traction-related complications are nil.6–8 Mei-Dan et al. reported on 1000 hips using traction table in the supine position with varying degrees of Trendelenburg, and found no groin-related complications among the entire cohort, including soft tissue or nerve-related injuries.6 Hip arthroscopy with a perineal post, on the contrary, was found to be associated with more venous blood flow obstruction and higher CPK levels, when compared to post-less distraction despite a threefold shorter traction time.13 Thus, it is not surprising that traction-related complications are mainly reported with the use of a perineal post. Recently, Schaver et al. were the first to evaluate early postoperative recovery following hip arthroscopy with and without a perineal post.8 The authors did not find any significant difference with regards to pain or morphine consumption, and they reported absence of complications including pudendal neuropraxia or groin-related soft-tissue injuries in both groups. However, their report did not include sciatic neurapraxia or foot and ankle soft-tissue injuries.

Traction-related complications are typically reported with traction time longer than 50–60 minutes.3,14 However, traction force can be a significant risk factor mainly in the setting of a short traction time.12 Telleria et al. evaluated sixty patients and showed that maximum traction weight was the greatest risk factor for sciatic nerve injury during hip arthroscopy. The odds of a nerve event increased 4% with every additional pound of traction.12 Recommendations for traction time and force are based on expert opinions so far, but recent evidence for hip arthroscopy with a perineal post suggested safety thresholds of 120 lbf, 82 lbf and 61 minutes for maximal traction force, mean traction force and traction time, respectively.15

This report has few limitations. The main limitation was that there was no tensiometer available to monitor traction force in the first procedure, since peroneal palsy was considered mainly related to the traction force associated with the use of a perineal post. Second, there was no electromyography performed to document the peroneal motor neurapraxia. In addition, the surgical setup including traction equipment was different between both surgeries. The traction boot was also different but both boots had similar padding protection thickness. The traction time was shorter during the left arthroscopy which could help in preventing traction injuries. However, the difference was insignificant and traction complications are typically reported with traction times beyond 50–60 minutes.3,14

Hip arthroscopy using both traction techniques were efficient in this patient, but the standard traction was associated with transient pudendal and peroneal nerve injuries. Surgeons should therefore be more cautious when they perform hip arthroscopy using traction with a perineal post.

Financial support and sponsorship

This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Informed consent

The patient has given their informed consent for the case report to be published. Given that this is a case report, the consent process was waived from submission to ethics.

Institutional ethical committee approval

The Institutional Research Ethics Board review was waived for the case report.

Author contribution

Johnny Rayes: Data collection, manuscript write-up and revision.

Ivan Wong: Study design, manuscript revision, supervision.

References

  1. , , , et al . Hip arthroscopy surgical volume trends and 30-day postoperative complications. Arthrosc J Arthrosc Relat Surg. 2016;32:1286-1292.
    [Google Scholar]
  2. , , , , . Traction-related problems after hip arthroscopy. J Hip Preserv Surg. 2017;4
    [Google Scholar]
  3. , , . Postoperative numbness: a survey of patients after hip arthroscopic surgery. Orthop J Sport Med. 2018;6:1-6.
    [Google Scholar]
  4. , , , , , . Complications following arthroscopic surgery of the hip: a systematic review of 36 761 cases. Bone Jt J. 2017;99B:1577-1583.
    [Google Scholar]
  5. , , , , , . Traction table – related complications in orthopaedic. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2010:668-675.
    [Google Scholar]
  6. , , , , , . Hip distraction without a perineal post: a prospective study of 1000 hip arthroscopy cases. Am J Sports Med. 2018;46:632-641.
    [Google Scholar]
  7. , , , , . Hip arthroscopy without a perineal post: a safer technique for hip distraction. Arthrosc J Arthrosc Relat Surg. 2007;23
    [Google Scholar]
  8. , , , , , . Hip arthroscopy with and without A perineal post: a comparison of early postoperative pain. Arthrosc J Arthrosc Relat Surg 2021:1-6.
    [Google Scholar]
  9. , , , . Ultrasound-guided portal placement for hip arthroscopy. Arthrosc Tech. 2016;5:e851-e856.
    [Google Scholar]
  10. , , , , , . Safety measures in hip arthroscopy and their efficacy in minimizing complications: a systematic review of the evidence. Arthrosc J Arthrosc Relat Surg. 2014;30:1342-1348.
    [Google Scholar]
  11. , , , et al . Pudendal nerve injury is a relatively common but transient complication of hip arthroscopy. Knee Surgery. Sport Traumatol Arthrosc. 2018;26:969-975.
    [Google Scholar]
  12. , , , , , . Risk of sciatic nerve traction injury during hip arthroscopy—is it the amount or duration? An intraoperative nerve monitoring study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2012;94:2025-2032.
    [Google Scholar]
  13. , , , et al . Effects of hip arthroscopy without a perineal post on venous blood flow, muscle damage, peripheral nerve conduction, and perineal injury: a prospective study. Am J Sports Med. 2019;47:1931-1938.
    [Google Scholar]
  14. , , , , , , . Femoroacetabular impingement: prospective study of rate and factors related for nerve injury after hip arthroscopy. J Orthop. 2019;16:350-353.
    [Google Scholar]
  15. , , , , , . A characterization of sensory and motor neural dysfunction in patients undergoing hip arthroscopic surgery: traction- and portal placement–related nerve injuries. Orthop J Sport Med. 2018;6:1-11.
    [Google Scholar]
Show Sections