“Redefining success in failed distal femur fracture fixations: The augmented nail plate construct (NPC) approach”
Article History
-
Received: ,
Accepted: ,
Abstract
Abstract
This study aimed to evaluate the clinical and radiological effectiveness of the nail-plate construct (NPC) in treating previously failed distal femur fracture fixations. Additionally, the study assessed patient-reported outcomes and mobility at a minimum of 2 years post-surgery, and reported complication rates.
A prospective study was conducted at Grant Medical College and Sir JJ Group of Hospitals, Mumbai, from January 2018 to December 2022. Seventeen patients with failed distal femur fracture fixations were included. The surgical technique combined locking plates (LP) and intramedullary nails (IMN). Post-operative protocols included early mobilization and customized rehabilitation plans. Outcome variables included bone fusion, malunion, post-operative mobility, weight-bearing status, length of hospital stay, complications, and Oxford Knee Scores.
The mean age of patients was 65.05 ± 7.26 years, with a mean follow-up of 26.23 ± 2.46 months. The radiological assessment showed a 94.11 % union rate, with 11.76 % delayed union, 5.88 % non-union, and 5.88 % malunion. The average postoperative Oxford Knee Score was 36.64 ± 5.49, with most patients achieving favorable outcomes. The average knee range of motion post-surgery was 109° ± 17.48°. Complications included superficial wound infection in one patient and initial degenerative changes in another.
The NPC technique demonstrated robust fixation and facilitated immediate postoperative mobilization without compromising union integrity. With a high union rate and favorable functional outcomes, NPC effectively mitigates the limitations of standalone nailing or plating. The findings support NPC as a viable option for managing complex distal femur fractures with prior fixation failures.
Keywords
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1 Introduction
Fractures occurring in distal femur are substantial, linked to an increased likelihood of morbidity and death.1 Young patients typically get these fractures from high-energy trauma, while elderly patients often suffer from low-energy mechanisms due to osteoporosis.1 The mortality rate at one year for geriatric distal femur fractures is as high as 26.10 % with one month and 6 month mortality also contributing so significant 8.14 and 19.5 % respectively.2 femoral fracture posed the highest risk for venous thromboembolism.3 Post-operative mobility has been enhanced in cases where distal femur fractures have been surgically addressed.4 Studies have demonstrated that engaging in early mobilization and being able to fully bear weight can decrease mortality rates, post-operative complications, and the length of hospital stay.1,4 Both anatomical lateral locking plates (LP) and intramedullary nailing (IMN) are recognized techniques for treating distal femoral fractures. Nevertheless, there are problems associated with using them independently with high nonunion and implant failure rates.1,5 (see Tables 1–3, Figs. 1–3)
| Variable | Value |
| 1. Age | 65.05 ± 7.26 (53–77) years |
| 2. Male:Female | 09:08 |
| 3. Right:Left | 10:07 |
| 4. High energy: low energy (mode of Trauma) | 11:06 |
| 5. Hospital stay | 11.23 ± 3.76 days |
| 6. OTA/AO fracture type | A = 6; B = 7; C = 4 |
| 7. Initial Management | Plating = 9; Nailing = 08 |
| 8. Follow-up | 26.23 ± 2.46 months |
| 9. Complications | 3 |
| 10. Mobility | Unaided = 10; Aided = 07 |
| 11. Post-Op knee ROM | 109 ± 17.48deg |
| 12. Post-op Oxford knee score | 36.64 ± 5.49 |
| Radiological outcome | Patients |
| Union | 12 |
| Delayed Union | 2 |
| Malunion | 1 |
| Non-union | 1 |
| Arthritis | 1 |
| Oxford Knee score | score | Patients |
| Excellent | >41 | 7 |
| Good | 34–40 | 6 |
| Fair | 27–33 | 2 |
| Poor | <27 | 2 |



When used individually as fixing procedures, both LP and IMN exhibit nonunion rates can be as high as 19 %.5 The malunion rate for intra-medullary nailing is 18.84 %, while locking plates reported 14.47 %.6 Dual plate fixation has been recognized as a viable alternative approach for fixation. However, the occurrence of nonunion and delayed union is reported to be as high as 12.5 % and 33.3 % respectively.7 The nail-plate construct technique used to treat distal femur fractures. It involves combining the use of locking plates (LP) and intramedullary nails (IMN) to achieve a fixation that is biomechanically favorable.5 This structure has the capacity to decrease the likelihood of improper healing and misalignment, enabling patients to move freely immediately following surgery without any limitations on weight-bearing.8 Consequently, this could result in enhanced ability to mobilize after surgery, thereby decreasing the chances of complications and death after surgery.5,8
The objective of this study is to: (i) asses clinical and radiological effectiveness of nail plus plate construct in failed distal femur fracture fixations; (ii) examine patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) and mobility in this group at a minimum of 2 year after surgery; and (iii) report on the rates of complications.
2 Material and methods
2.1 Study design
This Prospective study was conducted to assess the outcomes of augmented nail plus plate fixation in patients with previously failed distal femur fracture fixation. The study design included evaluating the presence of bone fusion and functional outcome after a minimum follow-up period of 2 years.
2.2 Setting
The study was conducted at Grant Medical College and Sir JJ Group of Hospitals, Mumbai. The patients were recruited from January 2018 to December 2022. All surgical procedures and follow-ups were carried out at the aforementioned hospital.
2.3 Participants
The inclusion criteria for this study were: (i) patients over 18 years old; (ii) patients with previously failed distal femur fracture fixation (either distal femur nail or lateral locking plate); (iii) radiologically proven failure of initial fixation (nonunion, malunion, hardware failure); and (iv) patients willing to participate in the study.
Exclusion criteria included: (i) significant comorbidities preventing operative procedures; (ii) active infection; (iii) acute fracture without prior fixation; and (iv) unwillingness to undergo operative procedures or refusal to provide consent. The study aimed to assess outcomes specifically in cases of previously failed fixation, excluding acute trauma cases.
2.4 Surgical technique
A lateral approach to the femur was performed for reduction and plate fixation, specifically a lateral parapatellar approach in the case of intra-articular distal fractures. A midline incision and patellar tendon splitting approach was performed to insert a retrograde femoral nail.
The fracture was successfully reduced and temporarily fixed using either a direct or indirect procedure, performed through a lateral approach. The reduction was visually checked and verified via fluoroscopy. A temporary k-wire/drill bit was placed through the distal locking hole of distal femur nail via zig. The k-wire/drill bit was positioned laterally and utilized as a guide for the placement of the lateral locking plate through a corresponding locking screw hole. This facilitated the straightforward alignment of distal screw holes in both the intramedullary nail (IMN) and locking plate (LP), enabling the placement of a single locking screw through both the nail and plate.
This way nail and plate implants were secured together by inserting at least one locking screw through both the distal locking holes of the nail and plate. The reason for this is that it produces a more uncompromising and steady structure.The surgeons considered this procedure to be beneficial, easy to use, and saw that it reduced the need for intra-operative fluoroscopy. Nevertheless, the authors did not examine fluoroscopy use or operative time in the current study.
2.5 Post-operative protocol
Every patient was administered prophylactic antibiotics at the beginning of the procedure, along with chemical prophylaxis for deep vein thrombosis (DVT) during the perioperative period. Patients were promptly permitted to bear weight with the help of walker and were encouraged to flex and extend their hip and knee as much as they could bear. In post operative period physiotherapy and rehabilitation plan for every patient was customized according to their pain tolerance level. Post 3 months all patients were subjected to knee Continuous passive motion (CPM) to achieve the desired flexion.
2.6 Variables
The primary outcome variable was bone fusion, (assessed using X-ray images and the modified radiographic union scale in tibial (mRUST) fractures.9 A mRUST score of ≥11 indicated radiographic union. Secondary outcome measures included malunion, post-operative mobility at knee joint, post-operative weightbearing status, post-operative length of stay in hospital, and any post-operative complications or returns to the theatre. Patient-reported outcomes were documented using the Oxford knee score (OKS) questionnaire.
2.7 Data sources/management
Data sources included patient medical records, X-ray images, and Oxford knee score questionnaires. Radiographic assessments were conducted by two clinicians with at least 4 years of orthopaedic surgery experience. Discrepancies were resolved by consensus, and the level of agreement between assessments was calculated as the percentage of identical ratings.
2.8 Bias
Efforts to address potential sources of bias included standardized radiographic assessment protocols and dual clinician evaluations to ensure consistency in outcome measures.
2.9 Study size
The study size was determined based on the availability of eligible patients within the recruitment period. A total of 17 patients met the inclusion criteria and were included in the analysis.
2.10 Quantitative variables
Quantitative variables such as age, hospital stay, follow-up duration, post op knee range and oxford knee scores were reported as mean ± standard deviation (SD). Variables were grouped according to clinically relevant categories, such as outcome according to oxford knee score (Excellent, good, fair, poor).
2.11 Statistical method
Statistical analyses included descriptive statistics for demographic and clinical variables. Union rates were calculated based on mRUST scores, with ≥11 indicating union and <11 indicating nonunion. Malunion was defined as an angular deformity of ≥5°. Agreement between clinicians was assessed using the percentage of identical ratings.
Data analysis was performed using SPSS software, and a p-value of <0.05 was considered statistically significant. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to evaluate the robustness of the findings. This structured approach ensures clarity and comprehensiveness in reporting the methods of this retrospective cohort study, allowing for reproducibility and critical appraisal.
3 Results
The initial sample size for this study consisted of 28 patients, but several participants had to be excluded due to various reasons. Two patients were excluded because they had active infections at the site of the fracture. As a result, they had to postpone elective surgeries and instead were treated with external fixation and antibacterial cement beads/spacers. Three patients, who were classified as ASA grade 4, were excluded from the surgery because to their substantial comorbidities that posed constant life threats. In addition, four patients refused to undergo surgical treatments and did not give written consent, while two patients did not show up for their planned follow-up appointments, leading to their elimination. In the final analysis, a total of 17 patients were ultimately included.
The study cohort's demographics indicated a mean age of 65.05 ± 7.26 years, with an age range spanning from 53 to 77 years. The cohort consisted of 9 males and 8 females, with 10 fractures on the right side and 7 fractures on the left side. In 11 cases, the trauma was caused by high energy, while in 6 cases, it was caused by low energy. The fractures were categorized using the OTA/AO system: 6 instances were classified as type A (extra-articular), 7 cases as type B (partial-articular), and 4 cases as type C (full articular). Initial management involved intramedullary fixation in 8 cases and lateral locking plating in 9 cases. The average hospital stay was 11.23 ± 3.76 days, and the mean follow-up period was 26.23 ± 2.46 months.
Two problems were documented during the course of the trial. During the early postoperative period, one patient experienced a superficial wound infection and did not exhibit any evidence of healing (nonunion) at the 2-year follow-up. As a result, further surgical intervention was required. One more patient showed initial degenerative alterations on the radiograph taken during the 2-year follow-up, indicating a potential need for surgery in the future. Every patient was capable of ambulating with the assistance of walking aids during the initial week following the surgery. During the most recent evaluation, 10 patients had the ability to move without assistance. However, 2 of these patients reported experiencing considerable discomfort while walking. The average knee range of motion (ROM) after surgery was 109° ± 17.48° at the 24-month follow-up.
The radiological assessment revealed that 12 patients had achieved union, 2 patients experienced delayed union (1.5 year post operative), 1 patient had malunion, 1 patient had non-union, and 1 patient had arthritis. The average postoperative Oxford Knee Score was 36.64 ± 5.49. Out of the total number of patients, 7 achieved excellent scores (>41), 6 achieved good scores (34–40), 2 achieved fair scores (27–33), and 2 achieved bad scores (<27). Overall, most patients experienced favorable functional results, with a high incidence of fracture healing and little sequelae. Most patients experience satisfactory outcomes based on the average postoperative knee range of motion (ROM) and Oxford Knee Scores.
4 Discussion
The use of the augmented nail-plate construct (NPC) in the treatment of failed distal femur fractures has shown promising results in our study. The study demonstrates that the NPC technique provides robust fixation, which facilitates immediate postoperative mobilization without compromising the integrity of the union. The 94 % radiographic union rate observed at the end of 2 years in this study with 6 % of nonunion and 11.76 % delayed union supports the biomechanical advantage of the combined use of intramedullary nails and locking plates. This dual fixation method mitigates the drawbacks associated with standalone intramedullary nailing or lateral plating, such as nonunion and malunion rates.
The studies by Basci et al.10 and Fontenot et al.11 support our clinical findings, showing the NP construct's superior durability. Basci et al.10 found combination had the highest cycles to failure versus plates and nails alone. Fontenot et al. demonstrated combination required 1.8 times more cycles to failure, achieving 100 % survivability. These biomechanical results affirm the nail plus plate construct's effectiveness in distal femur fracture fixation which are also observed in our studies.
Saraglis G et al. (2024)5 reported a 100 % union rate for distal femur fractures (fresh fractures), with a minor complication rate of 6.6 % due to superficial infections. Similarly, Pfister, B et al. (2023)8 observed a 100 % union rate in their sample, with patients able to bear full weight post-operatively and no cases of non-union or malunion.
Passias et al. (2021)12 found that NPC was significantly more effective, achieving a 100 % union rate compared to 69 % in the control group, especially for patients at higher risk of nonunion or with osteopenic conditions. Birjandinejad A et al. (2009)13 also reported a 100 % union rate for femoral nonunions, with no complications and 80 % of patients able to weight bear immediately.
In contrast, Gao, K et al. (2013)14 noted a nonunion rate of 15 % in patients treated with lateral plating and 6 % in those treated with retrograde nailing for extra-articular distal femur fractures. Our study's union rate is impressive given the challenging nature of the cases, which involved prior implant failures adding to complexity of implant removal to the case as well as bone loss during the process. The delayed union rate was 11.76 %, with nonunion and malunion rates each at 5.88 %. Despite these complexities, the overall success highlights the efficacy of the augmented nail plate construct technique in managing difficult fracture patterns and complications arising from previous surgeries.StudySample sizeUnion rateSpecial commentsSaraglis G et al. 2024515Distal femur fractures (periprosthetic & native)100 %complication rate was 6.6 % (superficial infection)Pfister, B et al., 2023816Distal femur fractures100 %full weightbearing post‐operatively with no cases of non or malunionPassias et al.,2021128 (nail plus plate)IM nailing (22 patients) locking plate fixation (67 patients)Distal femur fractures100 % in NPCVs69 % in controlmost effective for individuals at increased risk for nonunion or osteopenic or noncompliant patients.Birjandinejad A et al., 20091225 femoral nonunionsFemur + tibial non unions100 % union rateNo complications, with 80 % did immediately weight bearGao, K et al., 20131436 (19 lateral plating)+(17 retrograde nailing)Extra articular distal femur fractures15 % non union in plating group6 % in retrograde nailing groupOnly extra articular fractures were considered. Hardware failure was also seen in 2 casesOur study17 augmented nail plate constructDistal femur fracture fixation failure patients11.76 % delayed union5.88 % non-union and malunion each2 year union rate = 94.11 %Despite difficult fracture patterns and complication of cases due to previous implant removal 94.11 % of union rate was achieved
5 Limitations and future
The study's limitations include a small sample size, which restricts the generalizability of the findings, and the absence of a control group, making it challenging to compare the efficacy of the NPC technique against established treatments. Additionally, the exclusion of acute fractures means the results may not apply to patients with acute distal femur fractures.
Future study should use bigger, multicenter studies to validate findings across differed patient populations and improve external validity. Randomized controlled trials comparing NPC to alternative fixation procedures would give high-quality efficacy and safety data. Exploring how patient-specific factors like age, bone quality, and comorbidities influence outcome, could help tailor treatment plans, improving overall patient care.
6 Conclusion
The Augmented nail plate construct was able to exhibit strong fixation and make swift postoperative mobilization possible without compromising the integrity of the union. By virtue of its high union rate and positive functional outcomes, Augmented nail plate construct is able to effectively alleviate the constraints that are associated with standalone nailing or plating.
According to the findings, Augmented nail plate construct (NPC) is a promising approach for the management of difficult distal femur fractures that have been previously fixated but failed. Future studies with control group will be needed to standardize these results to general population and to attest effectiveness of this method of fixation.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Nadir Shah: Conceptualization. Niranjan Sunil Ghag: Writing – original draft, Formal analysis, Supervision. Akshay Punekar: Data curation. Mohammad Sohiel: Data curation.
Consent
Consent of the patient has been taken that his photo and detail can be published in article.
Ethical Statement
Hereby, I, Dr. Niranjan Ghag consciously assure that for the manuscript the following is fulfilled.1)This material is the authors' own original work, which has not been previously published elsewhere.2)The paper is not currently being considered for publication elsewhere.3)The paper reflects the authors' own research and analysis in a truthful and complete manner.4)The paper properly credits the meaningful contributions of co-authors and co-researchers.5)All authors have been personally and actively involved in substantial work leading to the paper, and will take public responsibility for its content.
Authors whose names mentioned below agree with the above statements and declare that this submission follows the policies of Solid State Ionics as outlined in the Guide for Authors and in the Ethical Statement.
Source of finance
Nil.
References
- Management of distal femoral fractures: a review article. Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics and Trauma. 2023;vol. 46
- [Google Scholar]
- Early and 1-year mortality of native geriatric distal femur fractures: a systematic review and time-to-event meta-analysis. J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2024 Feb 23;50
- [Google Scholar]
- Deep venous thrombosis following different isolated lower extremity fractures: what is known about prevalences, locations, risk factors and prophylaxis? Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg. 2013 Dec;39(6):591-598.
- [Google Scholar]
- The linked nail/plate construct for the management of distal femur fractures in the elderly. SICOT-J. 2024;10:20.
- [Google Scholar]
- Locked plating versus retrograde intramedullary nailing for distal femur fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. The archives of bone and joint surgery. 2022;10(2):141-152.
- [Google Scholar]
- Dual-plating in distal femur fracture: a systematic review and limited meta-analysis. Indian J Orthop. 2021;56(2):183-207.
- [Google Scholar]
- Best of both worlds? Fixation of distal femur fractures with the nail-Plate Construct. Orthop Surg. 2023;15(12):3326-3334.
- [Google Scholar]
- Sensitivity and specificity of modified RUST score using clinical and radiographic findings as a gold standard. Bone & joint open. 2021;2(10):796-805.
- [Google Scholar]
- Combination of anatomical locking plate and retrograde intramedullary nail in distal femoral fractures: comparison of mechanical stability. Eklem Hastalik Cerrahisi. 2015;26(1):21-26.
- [Google Scholar]
- Supplementation of lateral locked plating for distal femur fractures: a biomechanical study. J Orthop Trauma. 2019 Dec;33(12):642-648.
- [Google Scholar]
- Treatment of distal femur fractures with a combined nail-Plate Construct: techniques and outcomes. J Long Term Eff Med Implant. 2021;31(3):15-26.
- [Google Scholar]
- Augmentation plate fixation for the treatment of femoral and tibial nonunion after intramedullary nailing. Orthopedics. 2009 Jun;32(6):409.
- [Google Scholar]
- Retrograde nailing versus locked plating of extra-articular distal femoral fractures: comparison of 36 cases. Med Princ Pract : international journal of the Kuwait University, Health Science Centre. 2013;22(2):161-166.
- [Google Scholar]

